ADVERTISEMENT

Monday Morning QB

So what are the UDub Huskies doing right vs what ASU, AU and UCLA doing wrong..??

Chris Petersen has assembled a championship team without having but a few seniors or many other players, for that matter, from Sark's previous recruiting classes...

Ground zero for Petersen was his first recruiting class in 2014 and he has built this team from there and without JC players, either...

His recruiting team rankings from Rivals was #37 in 2014 with an average player rating of 2.78, #31 in 2015 with an average rating of 2.80 and #37 in 2016 with an average rating of 3.11...

Both UCLA and ASU had much higher ranked classes and average player ratings, by a fairly sizeable margin, while AU, using RR's "OKG" methodology, was a complete bust for the most part...

Petersen took a ton of freshmen and threw them to the wolves, mixed to a degree, initially with some of Sark's recruits in 2014 and the Huskies won 8 games and, in 2015, while adding more true freshmen to the mix, including QB Jake Browning and RB Myles Gaskin, the Huskies won 7 games...

Obviously, you have to factor in key injuries to both the Bruins and Sun Devils this season but it is still pretty interesting, to me at least, what Petersen has done at Wash using "his kind of players" that he emphasizes all of the time like he did at Boise St...

That's his model and he builds his program and team culture around it...

Obviously, he and his staff know what they want and are very good talent evaluators...

Meanwhile, at ASU we know that Todd and his staff have used a lot of JC players (that have a short shelve life) to bolster areas of need and have not done a particularly good job of evaluating a lot of HS players, esp on the defensive side of things...

There has been a lot of attrition this year but I'm still wondering about Todd's recruiting model vs a program like what the Huskies are doing under Petersen, keeping in mind that if they lost their top QBs what their record might be these days...

However, I don't think there is any doubt that their defense is light years ahead of the Devils defense in both talent and scheming and probably coaching as well...

It's been a wacky year in the PAC and hard to draw many valid conclusions, given all the key injuries, but Petersen is obviously onto something good at Wash in terms of his recruiting standards and player development...

Thoughts..??

Go Devils!!!

Tuesday Practice Report 11-1

ATTIRE: Helmets and shorts (bye week)
LOCATION: Kajikawa Practice Fields
MEDIA AVAILABILITY: ~15 minutes

EN VERDE (no contact): DB James Johnson

THE WALKING (OR LIMPING) WOUNDED: QB Manny Wilkins (right ankle getting taped), LB Salamo Fiso (right knee), LB Christian Sam (foot), DB Das Tautalatasi, DT JoJo Wicker, DL Edmond Boateng, WR Cam Smith, OL Sam Jones (foot), OL Stephon McCray (foot/ankle in a boot), WR John Humphreys, OL Tyson Rising

Other notes: QB Bryce Perkins was at practice and was not wearing a neck brace, but he wasn't dressed to play.

Personnel notes: Jason Lewis was working with the pass-rushers, Kyle Williams with the receivers. Also random, of anyone in shorts, Marcus Ball's were the shortest by a far margin. Tashon Smallwood was enjoying a chocolate milk on the drive over from the facility to the practice fields.

PURSUIT

ASU showed a drill had not previously seen in practice before called "pursuit," which consisted of a swarm of defensive players going together towards the football, with each eventually scooping a ball up and scoring.

Login to view embedded media
TACKLING

ASU again worked on tackling. With no pads on, Shawn Slocum wanted his players to focus on the contact point.

Login to view embedded media
OFFENSE

On the far side of the far field, the offenses went up against air. I did not catch all of the first, second and third teams, but I managed to see who was at QB for each.

First-team: Dillon Sterling-Cole
Second-team: Jack Smith
Third-team: Manny Wilkins

Wilkins moved as well I've seen him in weeks, in my opinion.

FIRST SONG IN THE CAR TODAY:

Login to view embedded media

As always, let me know of any questions, comments or concerns.

Bye Week Practice Schedule

Just wanted to give everyone a heads up on the modified schedule for the next week and half due to the bye week and a Thursday game versus Utah on November 10th.

There will be no Todd Graham press conference today because of the bye week, but there will be one a week from today on November 7th. Thus, no press conference article today.

We will have the regular Tuesday and Wednesday practice reports with post-practice videos and articles.

There is no practice or media availability on Thursday.

Next week there will be practice reports from the Sunday and Monday (November 6-7) practices, and on Tuesday November 8th there will only be post-practice video.

Hope this clarifies the unusual schedule for the next week and half.

Sunday Walkabout

Mornin Mates...

Today's Topic...Unfathomable

These things are unfathomable when talking about our Sun Devils today...

That our defense, when healthy, is lousy and when it is as depleted as it is now, it is downright putrid...

That we are having to play our fourth string QB, a true freshman, who is playing like a true freshman...

That our overall team attrition due to injuries needs more than a MASH unit to return to duty...

That injuries will mount when everyone is wearing a bag over their head as the season continues to head south...

That these things are happening as we face some opponents like Oregon that are very beatable these days but we're so bad we can't even do that...

That Graham and his staff are pulling down millions of dollars in salary for us to have to watch while our football team sinks...

To Todd's credit, the team doesn't give up but it is still a disaster to watch in this his fifth year on the job at ASU...

It is also unfathomable that in year five at ASU, our defense and especially our secondary, doesn't have enough PAC quality players to compete in the upper half of any conference, much less the PAC...

I mean what has he been doing over the past four to five years in recruiting..??

And, I don't see many DL and/or secondary recruits committed to us yet, either...

We also need some big time RBs for depth and other players that can contribute right away, to climb above awful back to lousy as a team...

I'm being a little melodramatic but it is not fun watching the Sun Devils get beat the way they are getting beat these days and things are not going to get better anytime soon that I can see...

I guess we can all take some solace in the misery of other teams in the PAC like our in-state rivals, the Mildcats down here in Southern Arizona, who are now win-less in the PAC, thank goodness...

Rich Rod will still collect his millions for also having a complete disaster on his hands, in his fifth year on the job, in the Old Pueblo, and Jim Mora, at UCLA, is still going to collect his millions in LA, despite having what he termed his best team ever at U-cla but the Ruins are 1-4 in the PAC so far...

At least Rich Rod has owned up to the fact that his "own kind of guys" that he recruited initially at AU were not up to the task at hand, while I haven't seen anything from either Graham or Mora confessing to the same sort of past recruiting mistakes...

Then you have someone like Chris Petersen at UDub who also recruits "his kind of guys" at Wash and he is smelling like roses these days in Seattle...

If this was the first year that something like this was happening at ASU that would be one thing but coming on the heels of last season, a losing one after having high expectations, you have to wonder if this is the new normal for ASU under Todd and his staff...

Again, a little melodramatic for effect but then again maybe not if our recruiting doesn't get better...

So, for me at least, it is totally unfathomable that we have been this lousy in Todd's fourth and fifth years at ASU, when you should have your system and players in place and enough of them to overcome some misfortune along the way but we don't...

Some will say wait until next year but I'm not so sure about that if we put another putrid defense on the field in 2017...

G'day Mates and Go Devils!!!

Fighting history ?

Since joining the PAC10/12 ASU has had 13 Seasons of 8 or more wins (38 seasons if my math is correct) they have done it back to back in 4 times 81-82 85-86 96-97 and 2012-2014.

Looking back on posts this is what many expect for ASU football, maybe fans need to accept ASU is in a current down cycle. The best 5 year cycle was 41 wins 78-82.

That could be broken this year. ( The cynic in me would point out the increase in the number of games played)



Did a quick look at U of Washington I think they had 18 seasons of 8 or more

Have an objective take... do not suck!

Your CTG, what three things do you need to do right the ship? Mine are:

1) new DC & approach
2) secure DB recruits --- solid 3 star kids, as too many swing for fence misses have made moving kids around and JC kids that take too much time to develop
3) review S&C program... too many guts, slow and poor energy players... more areas, but that is where I would begin...

Here's what happened when we blitzed

1)72 yd TD to Pharoah Brown
2)Comp to Jalen Brown for 6 yds & 1st down with Moeak covering
3)Complete to Carrington for 5 yards
4)Freeman ran for 8 yards and 1st down
5)Freeman run for no gain
6)Freeman run for 5 yard TFL
7)No pressure on 3rd and 7 and 1 of Herbert's only bad passes overthrowing wide open Carrington for sure TD
8)Complete to Jalen Brown for 23 yards
9)Brooks-Jones run for 17 yards
10)Complete to Pharoah Brown for 2 yds
11)Complete to Mundt for 17 yds
12)Complete to Pharoah Brown 4 yd TD
13)Complete to Nelson 5 yds
14)Incomplete to Crrington
15)Brooks-Jones run for no gain
16)Incomplete, Clhoun with pressure
17)Incomplete to Pharoah Brown thru his hands for sure 1st down with Moeak in loose coverage
18)1 yard run by Freeman
19)53 yard TD to Mundt
20)Brooks -Jones 8 yard TD run

Some positive takes

Harry's incredible effort/hustle/speed to catch the defender who had intercepted DSC in the end zone and catch him 85 yards away at the 15.

Lindsey's play calling. With Richard (our leading rusher who has almost twice as many carries as anyone else) and our leading receiver White who has nearly twice as many receptions as anyone else) and starting OL Jones/McCollum/McCray(hurt on 1st play of the game) out...........incredibly diverse and effective play calling. (478 total yds)

Nick Ralston--If only he had Ballage's talent. He is really a fullback that understands the game and blocking, being patient, picking holes, when to go and when to wait. And he delivers the blow. (On one play he caught it without forward motion and 2 defenders with a head of steam both bounded off him and he moved 1-2 yards further forward.

Kyle Williams--he may be small, but he can play. He is going to pay the price that so many others have for being bounced back and forth between offense and defense but my guess is that he ends up at safety in the Spring

Smallwood--had by far his best game of the season. His sack was from an assignment error where he was left totally untouched on a 3 step drop and direct shot from his spot at DE to the QB....but he also had 2 TFLs and 5 total tackles

Crump may had the first good pass defense that i have ever seen him play (albeit on only 1 play) but perhaps he can be more than a rush specialist. He had 10 total tackles, 5 solos, 1 sack and 1.5 TFLs

Stephen Miller/Cohl Cabral/Zach Robertson got desperately needed reps although many did not go so well

Justin Herbert

6'6" 215 True frosh Duck from Eugene Sheldon HS

3 star recruit with offers from NAU/Montana State/Portland State/Oregon

has played in 4 FBS games in his career
3-5 70 yds, 0 INTs, 1 TD vs Wazzu
21-34 179 yds 1 INT, 2 TDs 6 carries/6 yds vs Udub
22-40 258 yds, 1 INT, 6 TDs, 9 carries/56 yds vs Cal
31-42 489 yds, 0 INTs, 4 TDs, 11 carries/23 yds vs ASU

I saw a bit of his game against Udub in a complete blowout and didn't think much about him.

I saw most of the Cal game and although Cal has a terrible D, he looked VERY good for a true frosh

Today was a perfect storm for stat building (playing against the worst pass D in FBS for multiple years and getting them while they are missing their 2 best LBs and 2 best DBs)

BUT....he was 20-24 for 320 with 3 TDs in the 1st half!!!

He faced a blitz approximately 23 times (including stacked LOS on 3 plays near the end zone). According to Helfrich that is more than twice as much as he will face against any other opponent

He not only never looked frazzled or confused, he showed the poise of a seasoned vet with a very good arm, very good touch and good athletic ability.

Above all he appears to have "it"

Again, he has played against terrible to pathetic defenses in 2 of his 3 extended action games, but it will be interesting to see how he progresses. He seems to have completely silenced the critics stating that Oregon hasn't been able to develop a QB since Mariota.
  • Like
Reactions: pcock45
ADVERTISEMENT

Filter

ADVERTISEMENT