That's what former Tucson newspaper sportswriter Corky Simpson asks in his sports opinion piece in the Geezerville Times (Green Valley News) here in So Arizona this week...
The article features a picture of the 1897 Dartmouth national football championship team with the caption...
"Dartmouth's decision to unionize might not be such a good idea"...
Corky, in his Along the Way column, says that on March 4th the Big Green basketball team decided that they had "suffered enough" so voted to unionize with 13 team members for and only 2 against...
"The vote was supervised by the National Labor Relations Board inside Dartmouth's human resources office"...
So now an Ivy League school has a basketball team that is a member of the
Service Employees International Union Local 560...
Keep in mind that the players already get at least $83,802 of educational value for being on scholarship at the school each year...
As union members, the union has now told Dartmouth that they will now have to negotiate in good faith with the players through the union...
The Big Green used to be named the "Indians" but was discontinued 50 years ago in what Corky termed a "wave of guilt"...
Corky also goes on to point out that past Dartmouth alums that included Daniel Webster, Robert Frost, and Nelson Rockefeller, and dozens upon dozens of other notables, didn't need to unionize with which to succeed but Corky noted that none of those VIP alums could dribble and dunk and sink 3 point shots the way Big Green players can today...
So, there is that to consider, too...
Corky wonders if this unionization will create better working conditions for the players and whether they will end up with better wage increases, along with fully funded pensions, etc...
He also wonders if the players will get higher take home pay than their non-union opponents and what the minimum wage should be at the school where players can already collect on their NIL rights...
Corky concludes by saying "as absurd as this situation sounds at Dartmouth will this be the fate for all college players if they become designated employees of the school ?"...
And, it looks like this may happen everywhere and, if it does, he thinks that college arenas and stadiums may well become empty and, as the income disappears, intercollegiate athletics will become as "extinct as Native American mascots"...
I wonder what union local the Sun Devils will become members of in the future..??
Is it just around the corner or just an aberration that has happened at one Ivy League school..??
As Gordon Gekko would say..."greed is good"...or is it greed instead of just plain fairness..??
Stay tuned and Go Devils!!!